La pizzaiola is one of the pillars of everyday Neapolitan cuisine. This simple dish is a great solution for times when you want solid sustenance but don’t want to cook anything elaborate. A bit like slapping a piece of meat on the grill, only tastier.
The name of the dish, carne alla pizzaiola, translates loosely as ‘pizza-style meat’. That’s because of the tomato and oregano, a combination not as ubiquitous as non-Italians often imagine commonly associated with pizza. The dish goes by various names—manzo alla pizzaiola, fettine alla pizzaiola, bistecca alla pizzaiola—but, more often than not, simply ‘la pizzaiola’.
There are two ways of making this dish, quick or slow, depending on the kind of meat you are using.
For each dinner guest:
- 1 beef fillet
- 1/2 small can of tomatoes
- 1-2 cloves of garlic, peeled and slightly crushed
- Salt and pepper
- A pinch of dried oregano
- Olive oil
The Quick Method
If you are using tender, lean beef, then you want to opt for the quick version of la pizzaiola. In Italy, they sell thinnish (but not paper thin) slices of beef called fettine di manzo or just fettine. If you can’t find anything like that, you can use boneless steaks. If they are any thicken than say, 2 cm (1/2 inch) then you should cut them into half thicknesses. In either case, pound your slices with a meat pounder or the back of a heavy skillet. Pat each slice dry to ensure good browning.
Add enough olive oil to nicely coat the bottom of a heavy skillet. Turn the heat to high and, when the oil is very hot, quickly brown the garlic, taking care that it does not burn. Then add the beef slices and sear them quickly on each side. They should be just lightly caramelized. Don’t crowd the slices which would impede proper browning. You can do them in batches if need be. Remove the slices as they brown.
Don’t crowd the pan, mi raccommando….
Add an ample amount of best-quality canned tomatoes, which you can simply crush with your hands, to the oil. (In the summer, if you have really good ripe fresh tomatoes, just chop them up roughly and use them instead.) Lower the heat, season with salt, pepper and a nice sprinkling of dried oregano. Now, a word of advice: don’t go wild with the oregano. Even if it gives the dish its characteristic ‘pizza’ flavor, a little dried oregano goes a long way. You want its aroma to complement but not to overwhelm the taste of the meat.
After the pizzaiola sauce has simmered for a minute or two, add back your beef slices and any juices they may have exuded. Continue to simmer for about 10 minutes, until the sauce has reduced nicely and the meat is fully cooked through. You want to keep your sauce simmering at a moderate pace—not too slowly or the sauce will not reduce, but not too quickly either, which would tend to toughen the meat.
I usually love my beef ‘barking’ rare, but this is one dish where the meat really should be well done. The beef needs time to absorb the flavor of the sauce. And, for whatever reason, tomato sauce and rare beef do not really pair very well.
The Slow Method
The above method is perhaps the most common way of making la pizzaiola these days. The original recipe, however, used a rather tougher cut of beef, cooked slowly. According to the authoritative Jeanne Caròla Francesconi, author of the classic La cucina napoletana, the typical cut is called the colarda, taken from the rear leg of the steer. This is a cut that is not often found even in other parts of Italy. In other places, the costata (rib) or noce, a fillet taken from the inner thigh, are used. In the US, I’d use the kind of cut you’d use for a pot roast like a bottom round.
All the ingredients are placed together in a Dutch oven, covered, and simmered over low heat for about an hour. Add a bit of water or white wine if the sauce gets too thick. This method results in a wonderfully savory version of the dish, but it does not lend itself to a ‘spur of the moment’ approach.
Notes on La Pizzaiola
The measurements are really pretty loose in this dish. You may want to make ample sauce, which is wonderful with pasta, either as a first course to the meat or for another occasion, or just for mopping up with some crusty bread, something Italians call fare la scarpetta. The sauce from the slow method is, of course, much more savory.
Variations abound, in particular for the quick method. For a lustier sauce, add olives, capers, anchovies and/or a bit of red pepper flakes. Some recipes, including Francesconi’s, recommend adding a bit of white wine, which gives the sauce a little ‘zip’. Some recipes head in the opposite direction and omit the oregano and other flavorings in favor of a pure tomato sauce. (Frankly, that sounds a bit dull to me.) Some modern recipes will substitute the classic soffritto of onion, carrot and celery for the garlic. This produces a more ‘refined’ but less characteristic flavor. Not all recipes call for the initial searing of the meat slices, but I find that it lends a nice depth of flavor.
And if you are feeling particularly extravagant, try a gratinéed version of la pizzaiola. Arrange the cooked slices in a baking pan, nap them with the sauce and lay over slices of mozzarella. Place the pan under a broiler just long enough to melt the cheese, then serve. The basic method is very versatile. You can prepare other sorts of meat or even fish using the la pizzaiola method. Older veal, for example, does well, as do chicken or turkey breast. As for fish, choose one with nice, firm texture that will stand up to the assertive sauce. Say some swordfish, tuna or mackerel, cut into ‘steaks’. And you can even make hamburger patties this way!
- 1 beef fillet
- 1/2 small can of tomatoes
- 1-2 cloves of garlic
- Salt and pepper
- A pinch of dried oregano
- Olive oil
- If you are using tender, lean beef, then you want to opt for the quick version. In Italy, they sell thinnish (but not paper thin) slices of beef called fettine di manzo or just fettine. If you can't find anything like that, you can use boneless steaks (as pictured). If they are any thicken than say, 2 cm (1/2 inch) then I would suggest that you cut them into half thicknesses. In either case, pound your slices with a meat pounder or the back of a heavy skillet. Pat each slice dry to ensure good browning.
- Add enough olive oil to nicely coat the bottom of a heavy skillet. Turn the heat to high and when the oil is very hot, quickly brown a clove or two of garlic (taking care that it does not burn) then add the beef slices and sear them quickly on each side. They should be just lightly caramelized. Don't crowd the slices which, as you probably know, would impede proper browning—you can do them in batches if need be. Remove the slices as they brown.
- Add an ample amount of best-quality canned tomatoes, which you can simply crush with your hands, to the oil. (In the summer, if you have really good ripe fresh tomatoes, you can chop them up roughly and use them instead.) Lower the heat, season with salt, pepper and a nice sprinkling of dried oregano.
- After the pizzaiola sauce has simmered for a minute or two, add back your beef slices and continue to simmer away for about 10 minutes, until the sauce has reduced nicely and the meat is fully cooked through. You want to keep your sauce simmering at a moderate pace—not too slowly or the sauce will not reduce, but not too quickly either, which would tend to toughen the meat.
Hello sell my name is Glen I have really thin pork chops I would say a little bigger than maybe about a quarter inch and their freedom till they were Brown and now they’re simmering in the tomato sauce with a little basil parsley and oregano and some phenol I’m still practicing on how to make my own Italian seasoning blend I’m afraid I use hot sauce on everything and I smoke cigarettes my taste buds are probably slightly burn out hey way I’m making your dish working on it anyway and I’ve got some small shells and I’ll make me some pasta so thank you for the recipe anything from Naples or Palermo I’m getting recipes from all over the website even got two from the movie called The Godfather and Goodfellas my stomach and I appreciate what you do
Thanks so much, Glen, for your comment! I’m really happy you’re enjoying the blog. Hope you liked this dish, it’s one of my faves. And if you ask me, a little hot sauce wouldn’t hurt. Happy cooking, Frank
Hello Sal is my name it stands for Salvatore, I am from Catania, (sicily)
I do like cooking occasionally and my favourite dishes are: Carne alla pizzaiola and pesci spada alla pizzaiola, but there’s one problem with that, we love bread and with that sorts of food there’s never enough bread for the whole Family.
Thanks, Rocco! Glad to hear I'm up to nonna's standards… 🙂
ive read many pizzaiola recipie but this is the first one ive found to be accurate with how la nonna does it. went to visit her today and after having me do a million chores with my tools she had a huge plate of pasta with steak pizzaiola. she is the real deal by the way. 98 year old lady that does not speak a word of anything else but Niapolitan dialect.
complements to the cheff
these looks very good : ) i want try one
You’re a very good writer!
Mmmm, these looks so good! I definitely want to try these 🙂
Mmm. That looks fabulous. We will have to give this a try. Thanks for sharing both techninques.
I have not had this dish in so long, and I don't know why…..what a tasty way to prepare just about any meat!
I will have to revisit this recipe soon!
Great looking dish. Very traditional and homemade feeling to it.
Thanks folks! Your comments are really too kind…but keep them coming anyway. 😉
@Debbie: I actually have a post just on the subject of choosing canned tomatoes, which can be a little tricky. There's a link to it on the righthand column under “Basic Recipes and Cooking Techniques”.
@Kate: And thank you for the wonderful feedback. It's great to hear that these recipes are being made and enjoyed! But really you should thank Angelina: I'm just the messenger, passing on her recipes…
Frank, as always, a great recipe!! We made your eggplant parmesan the other night. I was a bit worried because my husband said absolutely nothing. Then, I realized he was just concentrating on plate to mouth, plate to mouth. I asked what he thought and he said, “This is the BEST eggplant parmesan I've EVER had.” Hopefully, I'll get it on my blog if that's ok with you. So, thank you very much!!! Kate@kateiscooking.blogspot.com
What an informative post! I didn't even know what pizzaiola was, but I do love pizza. I am excited to try something new, what kind of canned tomatoes do you use?
yummy! looks like so tasty! I'll try to make it soon.
I've died, went to heaven, and come back again so I can read more….ciao
yummy! what a delicious recipe! I want to take it tasty! 🙂
This looks like a dish that my hubby and kids (dedicated pizza lovers) would gobble up. And I love the idea of crushing the tomatoes with my hands!
I have been a little away from the blogs lately, but it's always great to come and visit you, you always have something deliciously authentic. I know of penne alla pizzaiola, but never tasted the meat.
Un piatto squisito, una delle tante icone della cucina italiana. personalmente penso che in questa preparazione, il manzo sia insuperabile. Complimenti.
I remember watching Everybody loves Raymond and Marry making her secret piazzola. From that moment I was hooked! I am so glad I have found your blog! Love the Italian cuisine!
I've never tried this dish…lokks amazing!
I don't know this at all. But with ripe tomatoes abundant – this would be the best time to try it. I like the lusty verions: anchovies, olives, etc. I am wondering if my family ever made this…
hey Frank, enjoyed reading this as I always do your posts – this sounds much how my Momma cooked her pork chops with canned tomatoes. Still is one I like to visit every now and again…