How many ways can you stuff a pepper? More than you can count, I reckon. Here on the blog we’ve taken a look at this quintessential summer vegetable stuffed with meat, tuna, pasta and eggplant. For this week’s post, here’s yet another one that’s dear to my heart, since it’s from the part of Italy where Angelina was born and grew up, a small town called Apice near Benevento: peperoni imbottiti alla beneventana, or Benevento Style Stuffed Peppers. You’ll find similarly stuffed peppers all over southern Italy.
You typically make this dish with a particular kind of pepper called corno di toro—literally “Bull’s Horn”— or cornetti ‘for short. They’re long and thin with pointed ends, and come in either bright red or yellow, looking very much indeed like colorful horns if you use a little imagination.
Peperoni imbottiti alla beneventana are filled with a savory bread stuffing flavored with typically southern Italian ingredients: tomatoes, anchovies, olives, capers, garlic and herbs. Traditionally, you sauté your stuffed peppers in olive oil until they are tender and cooked through, though these days many people roast them in the oven instead.
A simple but truly delicious dish that sings of summer, you can serve peperoni imbottiti alla beneventana as a side course, antipasto or as part of a summer buffet.
Ingredients
Serves 4-6 as a side dish
- 6-8 long peppers
For the filling:
- 300-350g (10-12 oz) day old bread
- 1-2 small tomatoes, diced
- 6-8 anchovy fillets, cut up
- 50g (2 oz) Gaeta style olive, roughly chopped
- a handful of capers, rinsed and dried
- 2-3 cloves of garlic, minced
- a sprig or two of fresh parsley, minced
- a pinch of oregano
- salt to taste
- olive oil
For frying
- olive oil
Directions
Prep and stuff the peppers
Cut off the tops of the peppers and gingerly remove the inner core and seeds while leaving the pepper intact.
Trim the crust off your bread, then crumble the rest with your hands into small pieces or briefly process in a food processor on pulse.
Place the crumbled bread in a mixing bowl. Add all the other filling ingredients except for the oil and mix well. Then drizzle over a bit of olive oil and mix again so as to moisten all the bread. Taste and adjust for seasoning.
Stuff each pepper with the bread mixture, a little at a time, packing it tightly.
Fry your peppers
Now, in a skillet large enough to hold all the peppers in a single layer, fry them in abundant olive oil.
Start over a medium high flame, standing the peppers up in the skillet open end downwards, so the stuffing browns and forms a crust. (You may have to do this holding up the peppers with tongs one or two at a time, depending on how high the sides of your skillet is.)
Then place the peppers on their sides and, lower the heat and partially over the skilled. Sauté the peppers gently, turning them from time to time, until they are cooked through and tender, about 15-20 minutes. Season them with salt as you go. The skins will wrinkle and brown lightly.
Serve
Serve still warm or at room temperature. If you don’t mind the calories, you can nap them with the frying oil for extra flavor.
Notes
Although they look very much like our Fresno chili peppers, cornetti peppers are sweet, not hot. They range in size from about 18-25cm (7-10 inches) long and weigh between 120-150g (4-5 oz). It’s the smaller red ones that are most commonly used for this dish. The most prized varietal of this type of pepper is the DOP designated peperone di Pontecorvo, from the eponymous town in southern Lazio.
The closest thing that I could find to cornetti where I live were some multi-colored “Sweet SNAPS” peppers. They didn’t have that lively red color, but they worked beautifully all the same. Otherwise any long sweet pepper or so called “frying peppers” will work, especially if you can find red ones. If all else fails, North American readers can order long sweet peppers online for Melissa’s Produce. And although I haven’t tried it myself, I imagine sweet “mini” peppers would also work well. Obviously you’ll need a lot more of them than called for above.
The bread for the stuffing would ideally be a nice loaf of pane casareccio you’ve made yourself. Otherwise, good quality Italian or French style country bread will work fine. The crumb should be sturdy enough to withstand crumbling without turning to mush. You can use fresh bread, but ideally you want day old bread, just slightly stale, so it soaks up the tomato and the juices from the peppers. But the moisture from the veggies isn’t super-abundant, so it’s best to avoid bread that’s gone completely stale.
And here a pro tip: Since you’re working with a long, thin pepper, don’t try to stuff it all at once. Rather, as directed add a little at a time, packing it into the pepper with one finger as far as it will go. then add some more, until the pepper is filled to the brim. Pack it well but don’t jam it, since the stuffing will expand a bit in the cooking. Make sure the last bit of stuffing is all or. almost all bread. If you want to be extra sure that the stuffing won’t ooze out, you can ‘cork’ the open end of your peppers with a small piece of a bread crust, or a bit of the crumb.
Variations
As mentioned, many modern recipes you oven roast the peppers rather than frying them. For this, place the peppers in a well greased baking pan, then season them with salt and drizzle them generously with olive oil. Bake at 190C/375F for 30-45 minutes, or until they are tender and cooked through. It’s probably best to use a bread crust ‘cork’ for this method or don’t fully stuff them. If you want to make this into a more substantial meal, place down a bed of potatoes and bake the peppers on top of them.
Measurements for the stuffing given in the recipe above are just indicative. The only measurement that really matters is the bread, since you’ll need enough to fill the peppers. I used 350g of bread, or 200g after the crusts were removed. That produced more than enough for 8 peppers. The flavorings depend entirely on your personal taste. Some recipes include a couple of tablespoons of grated cheese, either parmigiano-reggiano or pecorino romano, to the stuffing. For a vegetarian dish, you can just omit the anchovies.
Making ahead and leftovers
Since peperoni imbottiti alla beneventana can be served at room temperature, you can ceratinly make them ahead. If you have any leftover stuffing like I did, you can use it to stuff more pepper, of course, Or just enjoy it as it is, perhaps with a drizzle of wine vinegar. It make a perfectly delicious bread salad. Like panzanella on steroids!
Peperoni imbottiti alla beneventana
Ingredients
- 6-8 long peppers
For the filling:
- 300-350 g day old bread
- 1-2 small tomatoes diced
- 6-8 anchovy fillets cut up
- 50 g Gaeta style olive roughly chopped
- a handful of capers rinsed and dried
- 2-3 cloves garlic minced
- a sprig or two of fresh parsley minced
- a pinch of oregano
- salt to taste
- olive oil
For frying
- olive oil
Instructions
Prep and stuff the peppers
- Cut off the tops of the peppers and gingerly remove the inner core and seeds while leaving the pepper intact.
- Trim the crust off your bread, then crumble the rest with your hands into small pieces or briefly process in a food processor on pulse.
- Place the crumbled bread in a mixing bowl. Add all the other filling ingredients except for the oil and mix well. Then drizzle over a bit of olive oil and mix again so as to moisten all the bread. Taste and adjust for seasoning.
- Stuff each pepper with the bread mixture, a little at a time, packing it tightly.
Fry your peppers
- Now, in a skillet large enough to hold all the peppers in a single layer, fry them in abundant olive oil. Start with a medium high flame, standing the peppers up in the skillet open end downwards, so the stuffing browns and forms a crust. (You may have to do this holding up the peppers with tongs one or two at a time, depending on how high the sides of your skillet is.)
- Then place the peppers on their sides and, lower the heat and partially over the skilled. Sauté the peppers gently, turning them from time to time, until they are cooked through and tender, about 15-20 minutes. Season them with salt as you go. The skins will wrinkle and brown lightly.
Serve
- Serve still warm or at room temperature. Nap with the frying oil if you like.
Nutrition
Discover more from Memorie di Angelina
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
And you might also like...
Pasta alla gricia: The Mother of Roman Pastas
Carne cruda all’albese
Polpettone di fagiolini e patate
Melanzane al cioccolato (Chocolate Eggplant)
Tagliata di manzo con rucola e parmigiano
Bucatini alla pizzaiola
Cipolline novelle con piselli (Spring Onions and Peas)
Ribollita (Tuscan Minestrone)
Gamberoni alla griglia (Grilled Shrimp)
Pastiera Napoletana
Stuffed peppers really are a classic comfort food. I don’t think I’ve ever stuffed this type of pepper before, though…and the filling with the olives and capers sounds quite fantastic. Thanks for sharing, Frank!
And thank you for stopping by, David!
I’m bookmarking this recipe! The combination of anchovies, olives, and capers is so classic southern Italian. I can almost taste the Mediterranean sunshine in every bite.
So true, Raymund! Hope you like it.
these look so pretty Frank. And i like the addition of anchovies and olives. I used to make a similar sort of dish with stuffed capsicums. Delish!
sherry
This stuffing will work with so many veggies… Thanks for stopping by, Sherry.
15 minutes to have such a tasty lunch when the heat is on ?!?!?!?! We’re in !
Hehe! Thanks for stopping by, guys! 🙂
Just beautiful. And such pretty peppers!
Thanks, Mimi!
These look like the perfect finger food for cocktails. I love that they remain bright and colourful. I think I may try this on The Big Green Egg and that way I’m not standing at the stove. I hope I can find them but if not, I know I can get mini sweet peppers, which I know are not the same but it will make a tasty appetizer for sure.
Yes, I’m sure mini sweet peppers would work quite well. Enjoy!
As always, thanks for posting Frank. I love stuffed peppers and these look great. The challege for me will be to find the proper peppers.
Alas, it can be a challenge… but you can always find them online if nothing else works.
These look so, so, so moreish! Do not remember seeing similar peppers at an ordinary supermarket – they truly appeal visually and I can imagine the taste. Not difficult to prepare – the quality of the bread being of paramount importance methinks 🙂 !
Indeed!
I just love the stuffing. I have to look at the farmers market and see if they have the peppers. We stuff peppers in Germany with a ground pork and meat stuffing.
Also delicious, for sure.
THANK YOU for this recipe. When I got married in 1971 my aunt gave me our family stuffed peppers recipe: “as many Melrose peppers as you want, bread crumbs, anchovies, vinegar, oil” End of recipe! Tonight I’m going to use your recipe, which I know we will love, and another time subtract ingredients to match my memories.
Your aunt’s recipe does sound a lot like these, doesn’t it? Hope you like this version. 🙂
These peppers sounds fantastic, Frank. Long sweet peppers are hard to find here but, if I am lucky, the farmers market will have Jimmy Nardello peppers and they would be perfect for this. Love th4e stuffing — anything with anchovies. In fact, I am making Spaghetti all Gennaro tomorrow evening — just got my anchovies!
Thanks! And I agree. Even mhy meat-loving nephew enjoyed them! If you do try them with Jimmy Nardellos, do let us know who it works out. I’m sure readers will find it useful. And hope you enjoyed the Gennaro!
Excellent
Thanks, Miska!
Come desidero dí mangiare tutte le tue ricette. Ma dove io vivo i can’t find most of the ingredients! Mi godo le foto
Sei troppo gentile, Antoinette! E per quanto rigarda gli ingredienti, potresti quasi sempre acqusitarli online.
These look so good. We can easily find those peppers in Turkish stores or farmer markets.
Those look incredible! They call that style of pepper, Pimiento Romano in Spanish – they are very popular and there has been a real thing for stuffing them with wet Tortilla Español liquid (which firms up when cooked) recently.
That sounds delicious! I wonder how they kept the liquid from oozing out before it has a chance to set..